California Vehicle Code 23136 VC is a civil penalty. California has a "zero tolerance" law for underage drinking that makes it illegal for a person under the age of 21 to drive with any detectable amount of alcohol. Unlike a DUI, the driver does not have to be under the influence of alcohol or drugs to be convicted.
What Must Be Proven in an Underage Drinking and Driving Case?
In order to be convicted of VC23136, the following must be proven:
1. You drove a motor vehicle;
2. You were under the age of 21;
3. You had BAC of .01 percent or more measured by a PAS or chemical test.
In the United States justice system, a defendant is presumed innocent until proven guilty. The prosecutor has the burden of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt for the charge.
What are the penalties Underage Drinking and Driving?
VC23136 is a civil penalty and not a crime. Although it is not a crime, you will still face severe penalties from the DMV. Your driver's license will be taken and you will be issued a 30-day temporary license.
Your license will be suspended or if you do not have one than you will be delayed in getting one for a minimum of one-year at the end of the 30-days unless you request an Admin Per Se Hearing with the DMV within 10 days of being issued the citation or arrest. If you refuse to take a chemical test, your license may be suspended for 1 to 3 years.
If requested, your license will not be suspended until you are notified of the results of the hearing which can take several months.
Beware, you may be cited for VC23136 and charged with a traditional DUI charges such as VC 23152 or VC 23153.
What are the defenses to Underage Drinking and Driving?
The Detention was an Illegal Seizure under the 4th Amendment
When Law Enforcement pull you over, they have temporarily detained you under the 4th Amendment of the United States Constitution. In order for this detention to be considered "legal", the officer must have had at least reasonable suspicion, meaning at least some fact or information that suggests a law has or will be broken. Typically in a vehicle stop, the Officer claims to have seen a traffic violation including speeding, crossing lanes without turning signal, or an accident occurred. The Prosecutor has the burden of proving the Officer had reasonable suspicion. An experienced attorney will request video and audio recordings from the arresting Officer to challenge the reason for the stop.
The Arrest was made without Probable Cause
Under the 4th Amendment of the United States Constitution, an Officer must have probable cause for crime they are arresting you for. An Officer will establish probable cause for a DUI several ways. He will record smells of alcohol on your breath or coming from your vehicle, he will note your performance on Field Sobriety Tests (FST), and the results from the preliminary alcohol screening test (PAS). Each fact may be challenged in court. The presence of alcohol odor has no bearing on whether your impaired or your BAC. Officer routinely set drivers up for failure by administering confusing and complicated tests requiring extreme balance and precision without considering your medical and physical condition while being performed on uneven terrain with debris. PAS devices attempt to estimate your BAC by using a mathematical to convert alcohol content in your lungs to estimate BAC. This makes PAS results inherently less reliable allowing for challenge in court.
The chemical test results are invalid
Underage drinking and driving can involve extremely low levels of BAC. This may leave open avenues to challenge the results in the case. The Preliminary Alcohol Screening Test (PAS) must be calibrated and stored properly. Calibration records may show that a regular calibration date was missed. Chemical tests are similarly open to challenge. In addition, even if the results appear to be accurate they may be affected by recent use of mouth wash, acid reflex disease, or other medical conditions the officer was not aware of.
Bottom line, you need an experienced attorney who is willing to walk you through the entire process, evaluate your case effectively for weaknesses and exploit the issues in your case to achieve the best results. The Law Offices of Steven McNicholl has that experience and will get you through your case in the best shape possible.